Last month, I wrote about a riff that's in both the Moody Blues' "So Deep within You" from On the Threshold of a Dream and Rod Argent and Chris White's "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)," which was recorded after the Zombies broke up. At the time, I'd thought I knew an-other song that had a similar-sounding part, but I couldn't identify it. Recently though, I listened to an anthology of the Tremeloes, and I discovered that I'd been thinking of the beginning of "Hello World."
The phrase in "Hello World" is longer than those in "So Deep within You" and "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)," and it repeats more frequently. The song starts with it played four and a half times.
In "Hello World," it starts on a different pitch relative to the key than in "So Deep within You" and "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)," but the intervals are the same in all three (and the pitches of the first five notes are the same between "Hello World" and "So Deep within You").
(click the image to enlarge it)
(standard disclaimer that the notation may be wrong because I did it myself)
Unlike the other two, the notes in that phrase in "Hello World" are picked individually where the second of each pair of eighth notes are hammer-ons in "So Deep within You" and "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)."
According to the liner notes in my Tremeloes collection (Silence Is Golden: The Very Best of the Tremeloes), "Hello World" was issued as a single in 1969. On the Threshold of a Dream - the album on which "So Deep within You" appears - was also released in 1969 (specifically, April). Apparently "So Deep within You" was the B-side to the "Never Comes the Day" single, released the same month. According to the liner notes for Into the Afterlife, "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)" was recorded in March 1968, although it wasn't released until Into the Afterlife in 2007.
So I have even fewer answers than I did when I wrote my original post. Now I have three songs that were all recorded and/or released within about a year and that all share the same phrase.
When I listened to the Moody Blues' On the Threshold of a Dream last month, the recurring guitar riff in "So Deep within You" caught my ear. I figured out how to play it and confirmed that - save for the key - it's identical to a part in "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)," which was recorded by Chris White and Rod Argent shortly after the Zombies broke up. (There are two versions of "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)" on Into the Afterlife, but this riff is present only in the second version [track #18], the one with fuzz guitar.)
(click the image to enlarge it)
(standard disclaimer that since I did the notation myself, it might be wrong)
I didn't know how to indicate it in the notation, but the second note in each pair of eighth notes is a hammer-on.
In the Zombie Heaven liner notes, Paul Atkinson (the Zombies' guitarist) says that the Zombies were friends with the Moody Blues and used to go to their parties (p. 31). While that provides evidence that the Zombies and the Moody Blues knew each other, it's slightly misleading as far as guitar players, since Atkinson didn't play on "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)." The Into the Afterlife liner notes explain that it was Mac McLeod.
The chronology is also troublesome. The Into the Afterlife liner notes say that the session at which "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)" was recorded was in March 1968. On the Threshold of a Dream came out in April 1969. But "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)" wasn't released until the Into the Afterlife album in 2007. So while it would appear that there was some mixing of influences since the songs originated only about a year apart, since the riffs are so similar (with the same accidental even), and since the bands knew each other, it doesn't seem possible that the Moody Blues could have known "Telescope (Mr. Galileo)." Apparently, the similarity is just a coincidence.
At the end of October, I got (yet an-other) copy of the Zombies' Odessey and Oracle - the 30th anniversary edition put out by Big Beat that includes the whole album in both mono and stereo. As I've mentioned before, Odessey and Oracle is one of my favorite albums, and I've been working on learning how to play all of the songs from it. I've also been transcribing all of the lyrics. However, I was actually a bit disappointed when I discovered that this edition has all of the lyrics written out in the liner notes.
Mostly, it was the lyrics for "A Rose for Emily" and "Changes" that caused this slight disappointment. These liner notes claim that the first line of "A Rose for Emily" is "The summer is here at last," and yet - when compared to the rest of the song - it makes so much more sense if the first line is "Though summer is here at last." I wrote a more in-depth post about that here.
I'd been trying to figure out the exact lyrics for "Changes" for a long time. I'd seen people writing them as "I knew her when summer was her crown / And autumn sad how brown her eyes." Yet, I often heard it as "I knew her when summer was her crown / And autumn sighed how brown her eyes." I had been thinking about that particular line - whether it was "sad" or "sighed" - for months. To come up with an answer, I looked at the rest of the lyrics.
There is more than one instance in Chris White's writing where he takes the grammatical structure of one phrase and inverts it for the next phrase. For instance, in "Friends of Mine" - "That's something to see / That's nothing to hide." So I took this parallelism approach and applied it to the lyrics of "Changes." If the one line is "In spring her voice she spoke to me," it made sense to me that the complement was "And autumn sighed how brown her eyes." Both of those lines are linked by breathing (speaking and sighing) in the same way that the other two lines are linked by the concept of seasons as wearable items (summer as crown and winter as cloak).
That's how I interpreted the lyrics, but then I find that in the liner notes, it's listed as "And autumn sad how brown her eyes." Which is the very line that I had decided against based on parallelism.
I'm not sure where the lyrics in these particular liner notes came from - whether Rod Argent and Chris White were consulted or whether it's someone else's transcription, but I'm still going to hold to what I heard - "Though summer is here at last" and "And autumn sighed how brown her eyes." Based on the other lyrics of the songs, those make more sense to me, and - ultimately - give the songs more meaning for me.
As previously noted, I've been listening to all of the Argent albums I have this month. I've also been using this as an opportunity to make some progress on the Verulam Cover Project - my attempt to learn and cover all of the songs by the Zombies, Colin Blunstone, and Argent. Mostly, this has just been lyric transcription. And while transcribing lyrics, I noticed something, which led me to an idea.
Rod Argent and Chris White started sharing writing credits for the Argent songs, and I had the idea that it might be interesting to try to figure out whether a song is more of a Rod Argent song or a Chris White song. It seems that people are always trying to decide whether a McCartney/Lennon song is more McCartney or Lennon, so I figured I would try the same with a Argent/White song.
I would wager that "The Feeling's Inside" from Argent's eponymous debut album is mostly a Chris White song for two reasons.
First, there's the line "there is nothing to hide," referring to someone's love. This is extremely similar to a line in "Friends of Mine," which is undoubtedly a Chris White song. In "Friends of Mine," there's the chiasmus "that's something to see / that's nothing to hide," again referring to love.
Second, there's a chromatic descending bass part that goes from A to G to F# (and then to lower notes which I haven't figured out yet). This is also characteristic of White's writing; this same thing occurs in "Brief Candles" (both descending and ascending) and in "Don't Go Away" (though only ascending)
So between the lyrical and musical similarities with his earlier work, I'm almost certain that "The Feeling's Inside" is a Chris White song.
I've run across this enough times that I feel something needs to be said about it. The first line of the Zombies' "A Rose for Emily" is "though summer is here at last." I think that every time I've seen the lyrics written out - even in the sheet music I have of the song - it's rendered as "the summer is here at last." And while just listening closely enough will reveal that it's actually "though," looking at the rest of the lyrics provides sufficient evidence.
The first stanza sets up the contrast between summer and loveless Emily, which the rest of the song develops. Summer is usually seen as one of the best times of the year, but despite that fun connotation, Emily's life is sort of dismal.
She watches her flowers grow
While lovers come and go
To give each other roses from her tree
But not a rose for Emily
Emily, can't you see there's nothing you can do
There's loving everywhere but none for you
And while much of the song talks about this by illustrating the contrast between Emily and the other lovers, it is also illustrated by the contrast in the weather: "Though summer is here at last / The sky is overcast." Summer is usually a time of enjoyable weather, but here "the sky is overcast." The though indicates the opposition between the first two lines.
"The summer is here at last / The sky is overcast" does not have that opposition, and it seems choppy and contradictory. Though signifies a subordinate clause, which improves upon both of these shortcomings. It illustrates that the two lines are grammatically connected and intentionally opposite.
I've finally started doing the idea I had back in February. Namely, listening to all of my Argent albums every week in August (also, alliteration). However, since I decided to do that, I bought Circus. It had worked out perfectly: seven albums for seven days of the week. Now I have eight albums that I have to squeeze into seven days. So I've decided to listen to Greatest: The Singles Collection and Encore on Sunday and then listen to the other albums on the rest of the days of the week, going chronologically:
Monday: Argent
Tuesday: Ring of Hands
Wednesday: All Together Now
Thursday: In Deep
Friday: Nexus
Saturday: Circus
So because to-day is Thursday, I listened to In Deep to-day. And I realised a few things:
I've heard "God Gave Rock and Roll to You" dozens of times, but until to-day, I had never been able to understand what Rod Argent sings at about 3:45. It's "To every boy he gave a song to be sung."
I'm pretty sure that Rod Argent musically quotes some classical piano piece in "Be Glad." I'm fairly certain that it's something he later recorded for Classically Speaking, but I have yet to listen to both albums back to back and figure out which one it is.
I revisited an earlier idea I had about "Candles on the River" and figured out something interesting. According to Bob Henrit's comments on the LP sleeve, "Candles on the River," while billed to "Argent/White," is mostly a Chris White song. And the "candles" part reminded me of "Brief Candles" from the Zombies' Odessey and Oracle, which Chris White also wrote. He re-uses the metaphor of people as candles. But then I remembered that that wasn't his original idea; he took it from Aldous Huxley's collection of short stories titled Brief Candles. And Huxley took "brief candle" from Shakespeare's Macbeth. But I realised that Shakespeare didn't really come up with the metaphor of people as candles either. It's in Isaiah 42: "Behold my servant, whom I uphold, my chosen, in whom my soul delights; I have put my Spirit upon him; he will bring forth justice to the nations. He will not cry aloud or lift up his voice, or make it heard in the street; a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench." (Emphasis added.)
Which has a lot of interesting connections. Even though it doesn't appear that Chris White was familiar with the "brief candles" line in Macbeth, the Zombies did list Shakespeare as an influence. There's a quote from The Tempest in the original liner notes to Odessey and Oracle. Similarly, while Argent (the band) may not have recognized the Biblical reference that the people/candles metaphor has, there are religious influences in their work. There's the musical quotation of the Latin hymn "Dies Irae" in "The Coming of Kohoutek" from Nexus. In the version of "Hold Your Head Up" on Encore, Rod Argent includes part of "God of Grace and God of Glory" in his solo. And there are also religious connections (or at least hints to them) in "God Gave Rock and Roll to You," "Gonna Meet My Maker," "Music from the Spheres," and "Rejoice."
So even though it doesn't appear that these bands realized where some of their references came from, the references still fit within the context of the band's past work and acknowledged influences.
I've been listening to the Zombies everyday this month, and the weekends have consisted entirely of their live albums. Excluding the fourth disc of Zombie Heaven (which is the same as the Live on the BBC album and which I've been listening to on Tuesdays), I have four live albums - Live at the Bloomsbury Theatre, London (which is technically a Colin Blunstone & Rod Argent album), Odessey and Oracle 40th Anniversary Concert, Live at Metropolis Studios, and Extended Versions. Because these are all a few years apart (2005, 2008, 2011, 2012), it's been really interesting to hear how their live shows have evolved.
"She's Not There" presents the best example. In the later versions, there's a guitar part at the beginning of the second verse that isn't in the original 1964 recording, but it seems to have become a part of the song. In fact, I sometimes wonder if that part would have been in the original recording if it had been written at the time. It seems like the kind of addition that becomes integral to the song.
In the Live at the Bloomsbury Theatre, London version, it's not there. Keith Airey has a guitar solo later in the song, but it's structured in the same manner as Rod Argent's electric piano/organ solo (an organ solo seems to be a standard addition to the recorded version, too).
The Odessey and Oracle 40th Anniversary Concert version is probably the closest to the recorded version (when comparing these four). The extra guitar part isn't there, and Rod Argent doesn't extend his solo to the organ. The only instrumental difference between this version and the 1964 recording is that this one includes brass parts.
It appears on Live at Metropolis Studios, on Extended Versions, and on the version they did at SXSW, and since all of those performances were when Tom Toomey was with the Zombies, I'm wondering if he wrote that riff. Since it doesn't appear before his time as a Zombie, it's quite possible.
---~---
"Time of the Season" is a bit more consistent, but there are a few interesting changes. The version on Live at the Bloomsbury Theatre, London has a really fast tempo. It's almost as if they're rushing to get to the end of it. Jim Rodford also sings some of the parts - "Is he rich?" "To show." While the tempo is a lot faster than the original recording, the vocal part distribution is the same; Jim Rodford takes over Chris White's parts both on bass and on vocals. But on all of the other versions I've heard since that one, Rod Argent has taken those extra vocal parts. Frankly, I don't understand why. I like the way it was originally written, and I don't think that Jim Rodford gets enough distinct vocal parts. (His vocal part on Argent's "He's a Dynamo" is one of the reasons I love that song so much.)
The versions on Live at Metropolis Studios and Extended Versions also include an interesting chromatic organ part in between "is he rich like me" and "has he taken any time to show you what you need to live."
This isn't in the version on Live at the Bloomsbury Theatre, London, but you do get a hint of it on the version on Odessey and Oracle 40th Anniversary Concert.
The version that they did of "Time of the Season" at SXSW has an interesting feature too - while playing his organ solo, Rod Argent also plays chords on electric piano. I think it's a great addition to the song because it's different, but it's not as drastic a change as writing a new part would be.
---~---
I think it's great that they're still touring and playing these songs, and their changing different parts proves that they're still invested in what they're doing and that they're enjoying themselves.
I realise that I wrote a blog post just yester-day, but I'm writing an-other one to-day. I also realise that I said I would write a post about FAWM in a week or so. This isn't that.
But I effected a rather significant change to-day, which got me thinking about other stuff, so I'm writing this.
At the very end of November, I started this project where I record a hymn every week. My knowledge of musical notation had effectively evaporated from the minimal amount that I'd learned from 6th grade band, and what I learned in piano class two years ago didn't really stick, so I thought that this project would help to rekindle it. (I decided on hymns because I'm familiar with the melodies and I have a hymnal, which contains the music.) I believe that, even at the on-set, I made connexions between my project and Rod Argent's teaching himself to sight read and Roger McGuinn's monthly recording of a folk song.
I don't even remember where I read it, but I learned somewhere that Rod Argent sat down for an hour or two a day everyday and practised sight reading pieces until after two or three years he could do it to some degree of skill. (And since it's Rod Argent, you can bet that it's a high degree of skill.)
Back in April, I learned about Roger McGuinn's Folk Denvia NPR. This is a project where he records a folk song every month. He's been doing it for something like fifteen years and hasn't missed a month yet, which is pretty impressive. (I'm considering doing the same thing in 2013 if I can learn enough folk songs.)
So I sort of just took those two ideas and combined them - a set schedule, like McGuinn's, by which I would learn musical notation, not as impressive as Argent's sight reading, but still similar. I've been doing that for about three months now, but to-day I transitioned from guitar to mandolin, for a few reasons:
I've been playing guitar for over four years, so I know the fret board pretty well by now. I've been playing mandolin for only about two and a half years (and only about one and a half years if you measure by any sort of proficiency). I figured that by moving to mandolin, I would not only continue to learn musical notation, but I would also become more familiar with the mandolin fret board.
Up until now, I'd recorded everything with electric guitar, and now I have to record mandolin acoustically. I get really nervous about recording things acoustically, so I figured that forcing myself into doing that would help to allay my apprehension.
It also doesn't hurt that mandolin players are fairly rare when compared to the glut of guitarists.
February Album Writing Month ended yester-day. I did complete my fourteen songs though it seemed to be more of a challenge this year than last year. I'm going to put that off to my depriving myself of string instruments and not really planning anything. I'm planning on writing a more in-depth post about FAWM within a week or so.
In order to indoctrinate myself to keyboard-based songs, I listened to Rod Argent's Classically Speaking everyday from 22 January to 28 February. But now since FAWM is over, I don't have to do that anymore. I enjoyed it though - listening to something multiple times (and especially with that sort of frequency) naturally causes one to become more familiar with it. So I sort of want to do that again this month with a different album.
But while I was trying to decide which album I should listen to every month, I noticed that I have stacks of albums that I haven't even listened to once. So I'm going to postpone that intensive every-day-for-a-month album listening for awhile. Instead, I'm going to work my way through the albums that I haven't listened to yet. But even before I get to those, I'm going to listen to the CDs that I've borrowed from my sister. (Many of which I've had for about a year.)
So to-day I'm starting a project which essentially entails listening to something new everyday. If you're so inclined, you can follow my progress over on the music listening journal I started at the beginning of the year. Asterisks indicate the first time I've listened to something.
One of my minor musical projects for 2013 is to listen to the Zombies' Odessey and Oracle every Monday and the Moody Blues' Days of Future Passed every Tuesday. It started out as just Days of Future Passed on Tuesdays because 2013 began on a Tuesday and that's the album that contains "Tuesday Afternoon," but soon after, I added Odessey and Oracle just because I like it so much.
So far, I've been able to keep up with it (excepting one Monday when I was terribly ill).
For February Album Writing Month, I've excluded all string instruments and written all of my songs with at least some keyboard element. In order to indoctrinate myself to that particular paradigm, I've listened to Rod Argent's Classically Speaking everyday for the past three weeks or so.
Because I've been listening to these albums so much, I've been able to pick out things that I hadn't heard before. For instance, I hadn't realised how prominent the sound of the mellotron is for Days of Future Passed or Odessey and Oracle. And I like having that; it's like I'm rediscovering music that I've known for years.
Last night, I realised that I have five Argent albums (Argent, Ring of Hands, All Together Now, In Deep, and Nexus) and that it would be interesting to listen to one of those for each day of the week. I later expanded this to include the live album from 1974 and the greatest hits album I have, which includes different versions of the songs, such as the edited singles. That makes seven albums - one for each day of the week. So I decided to make this a project I'll do in August - listen to one Argent album everyday.
But then the more I got thinking about this, the more I realised that other groups could fit into this paradigm too (though they aren't as alliterative). I have five Colin Blunstone albums (One Year, Ennismore, Journey, The Ghost of You and Me, and On the Air Tonight) - there's an album for every weekday of July. And for June, I could have two albums by the Zombies. One set of the original albums (Begin Here, Odessey and Oracle, New World, As Far As I Can See, and Breathe Out, Breathe In) and one set that includes the four discs of Zombie Heaven and Into the Afterlife, which includes some more Zombies songs and transitional tracks from the Zombies to Colin Blunstone and Argent.
I'll have to do some more planning to figure out specifically what albums I have to listen to on what days, but I think this is a good idea and it's certainly a thing I'm going to try to do. Not only will it allow me to become more familiar with the artists that I enjoy, but it was also further cement them into my brain so that - with any luck - the songs I write will more closely resemble the songs that influenced them.
Four years ago to-day, I had a headache. I don't remember why (if I ever knew at all), but despite that headache or perhaps even because of it, I finally sat down to figure out how to play the guitar that I'd owned for three months.
I listened to the Peter, Paul, and Mary version of Bob Dylan's "The Times They Are A-Changin'" with the chords and their corresponding pictures set out in front of me, and I learned to play it on the $100 guitar I'd gotten at the grocery store.
The main motivating reason that I wanted a guitar in the first place was because of a song by the Byrds - "So You Want to Be a Rock and Roll Star."
So you want to be a rock and roll star Then listen now to what I say Just get an electric guitar And take some time and learn how to play
They just made it sound so easy. It wasn't until months later that I would learn that it was actually a satirical song aimed - in part - at the Monkees, whose television show I had recently discovered and was watching and enjoying.
During those four years, I've learned a lot about music. I got an acoustic guitar, then a mandolin, a bass guitar, a second electric guitar, and - just a month ago - an electric twelve-string. It seems I write something like this every year or so, but I always see it as a process. There isn't really an end to anything; it's just a continual process of getting better and learning more. Recently, I've taken greater steps toward that. Currently, I'm in the midst of February Album Writing month, and in order to challenge the monopoly that stringed instruments have held on my composing virtually since its inception, I'm constricting myself to non-stringed instruments. Electric piano has formed the basis so far, largely due to Rod Argent's influence.
But because I've been thinking a lot about music lately, I thought I would create a blog that's more suited towards long text posts than my tumblr is. Here, I can actually flesh out ideas I have without feeling guilty that I'm taking up too much space on anyone's dashboard. (I can also avoid the insane fanatics that creep on the tumblr tags.)
Academically, I'm an English major, and I've taken that method of thinking and applied it to song lyrics. I've come up with some interesting ideas, yet there doesn't seem to be any place to discuss song lyrics to any great depth, or at least not the songs lyrics that I listen to. So that's why I started this - to talk about the music I enjoy and the thoughts I have about it.