Monday, January 12, 2015

Billy Joel's "She's Always a Woman"

Last week, I happened to hear Billy Joel's "She's Always a Woman" while at the store, and it occurred to me how parallel two of the lines are:  "Oh--and she never gives out / And she never gives in."  Except for the "out" and "in" (prepositions acting in verb-adverb combinations with "give"), which are opposites, the lines are virtually the same.  It's interesting that those two words can provide such an opposition while - individually - the lines are saying distinct things.  So you can understand that "she never gives out," "she never gives in," and - like the language used to describe her - she's seemingly contradictory and embodies opposition.  The next line ("She just changes her mind") confirms this.

I looked in the liner notes of The Stranger (the album on which "She's Always a Woman" appears) to find the lyrics (it's faster than transcribing them myself, although I did notice some small discrepancies between the printed lyrics and the sung lyrics), and I found two other similar instances.  The first is the first two lines:  "She can kill with a smile / She can wound with her eyes."  Both lines are structured the same way and indicate the woman's hostility.  Later, there're the lines "She is frequently kind / And she's suddenly cruel," which - along with their structural parallelism -  demonstrate her erratic nature.  However, I don't think either of these pairs of lines has the same sort of implication as "Oh--and she never gives out / And she never gives in."